--- title: "Anonymity Loves Company" subtitle: "A coin in self-custody can outlast any rule the new left writes. Its privacy cannot, because privacy is made from other users, and how many there are is now a political question." excerpt: "On December 5, 2010, with the payment companies cutting off WikiLeaks one by one, Satoshi Nakamoto asked WikiLeaks not to use Bitcoin. Sixteen years later the Trump family's coins have made crypto a Republican brand, the left that beat the industry's money will write the next rules. A coin already in your own wallet stays there. Its privacy depends on a crowd, the crowd depends on politics, and the left has just learned, from the receiving end of American payment power, why it might want money that nobody can switch off." coverImage: "/assets/blog/anonymity-loves-company/cover.png" category: "Crypto" tags: ["Monero", "Bitcoin", "Privacy", "Social Democracy", "Midterms", "Digital Cash", "Digital Euro", "Cypherpunk", "WikiLeaks"] date: "2026-11-19" author: name: synapz picture: "/assets/blog/authors/profile.png" ogImage: url: "/assets/blog/anonymity-loves-company/cover.png" --- In the first week of December 2010, the payment companies cut WikiLeaks off one at a time. The site had begun publishing a quarter of a million US diplomatic cables at the end of November. [PayPal blocked its donations](https://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2010/12/07/visa-mastercard-move-to-choke-wikileaks/) on Friday, December 3. On Monday a Swiss bank froze Julian Assange's account and MasterCard stopped processing payments to WikiLeaks, and Visa followed on Tuesday morning. WikiLeaks had not been charged with a crime anywhere. It later counted Bank of America and Western Union among the companies maintaining what it called [a banking blockade](https://wikileaks.org/Banking-Blockade.html). On Sunday, December 5, between PayPal's decision and Visa's, a thread on the Bitcoin forum was debating whether WikiLeaks should take bitcoin instead. Bitcoin was not quite two years old. One member had welcomed the prospect the day before: "Basically, bring it on." The project's pseudonymous founder [replied](https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/posts/bitcointalk/523/): > No, don't 'bring it on'. The project needs to grow gradually so the software can be strengthened along the way. I make this appeal to WikiLeaks not to try to use Bitcoin. Bitcoin is a small beta community in its infancy. You would not stand to get more than pocket change, and the heat you would bring would likely destroy us at this stage. Six days later, in a thread about a PC World article on Bitcoin, Satoshi [wrote](https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/posts/bitcointalk/542/): "It would have been nice to get this attention in any other context. WikiLeaks has kicked the hornet's nest, and the swarm is headed towards us." The next day he [posted a software release](https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/posts/bitcointalk/543/) with some new defenses against denial-of-service attacks, warning that "there are still more ways to attack than I can count." It was his last post on the forum, and nobody knows whether the timing meant anything. The inventor of money that no payment company could block was asking a publisher that every payment company had just blocked to stay away. He gave two reasons. The network was too small to be worth much to WikiLeaks, and the attention WikiLeaks would bring could destroy it before the software was strong enough to survive. WikiLeaks [began accepting bitcoin](https://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2011/06/14/wikileaks-asks-for-anonymous-bitcoin-donations/) in June 2011, after Satoshi had left the forum. I have been rereading that post since November 3, because of two questions I have not managed to answer. The first is whether Donald Trump and his family's crypto ventures have poisoned crypto for the social democrats who just took Congress, the Warrens and Sanderses of the next generation, and whether anyone among them, in North America or anywhere else, sees the technology as a way to lift people out of poverty or out from under a state that oppresses them. I am left of center, I live in Toronto, and I have written about crypto on this site for years, and for most of that time the combination has felt lonely. The second question comes from the other side, from people who hold the coins I care about. If the point of crypto was to leave the banking system and be a bank unto yourself, who cares what Congress or an exchange's compliance department decides? A Monero holder whose coins sit in her own wallet loses nothing when an exchange delists them, apart from an easy way to buy more. Staying out of sight of banks and regulators was the goal, and someone holding Monero might fairly ask whether people like me, fretting about the left's crypto policy, have lost the plot. Satoshi's post answers the second question, and the answer leads back to the first. ## What the Casino Bought The first question has a short answer if "crypto" means the industry. In June, [Reuters found](https://www.reuters.com/investigations/under-trump-crypto-playbook-family-always-wins-investors-dont-2026-06-09/) that the Trump family had made at least $2.3 billion from World Liberty Financial, the $TRUMP memecoin, ALT5 Sigma, and American Bitcoin, while investors in the same ventures had lost about $2.3 billion. Voters had drawn the connection by spring. In an April [Politico poll](https://www.politico.com/news/2026/05/13/poll-congress-crypto-voters-00918729), more than 35 percent of Americans associated Republicans with "supporting the interests" of the crypto industry and 14 percent said the same of Democrats, and Harris voters opposed government action to legitimize crypto by 40 to 23 percent. After the CLARITY Act, the industry's market-structure bill, failed in the Senate in September, the industry's largest super PAC [backed only Republicans](https://www.reuters.com/legal/transactional/crypto-blitzes-midterms-with-176-million-support-allies-it-prepares-post-trump-2026-10-27/) in Senate races. Then the money lost. Of the twelve competitive races that had been called by the day after the election, [Molly White counted](https://www.citationneeded.news/2026-election-results/) nine in which the side crypto PACs backed lost, with $74.7 million spent on the losing side and $28.3 million on the winning one. Sherrod Brown beat Jon Husted in Ohio after the industry spent more than $64 million against him, "the most the industry has ever spent on a single race." Angela Gonzales-Torres, one of six members of the Democratic Socialists of America newly elected to Congress, unseated an incumbent in Los Angeles and [told her supporters](https://www.democracynow.org/2026/11/9/angela_gonzales_torres) that "Los Angeles doesn't belong to AIPAC, right? Los Angeles doesn't belong to crypto or big AI lobbies." In her first national interview, crypto came up again only as money to get out of politics. Elon Musk put at least [$445 million](https://apnews.com/article/musk-midterm-texas-talarico-2bae8618952e9688a5f33ce422a063a2) behind Republicans, and [more than $200 million of it in Texas](https://www.theverge.com/policy/1026329/elon-musk-paxton-talarico-texas-election-funding), where Tesla and SpaceX are based. His spending helped Ken Paxton through the Republican primary. In November, James Talarico beat Paxton by more than twelve points. Talarico had answered one of Musk's posts during the campaign: "There is something deeply wrong with a political system that allows one trillionaire to buy his own personal US Senator." Democrats also [took the governorship](https://www.wired.com/story/voters-set-dollar400-million-of-elon-musks-money-on-fire/), the office that oversees more than $1.6 billion in tax incentives for Musk's Texas operations. Justin Slaughter, a senior advisor at Paradigm, a crypto investment firm, gave an account of the damage on [the Law of Code podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/interview-what-the-2026-midterms-mean-for-crypto-and/id1578287932?i=1000800025403), recorded the day after the election, and he predicted no crackdown. Of the seventeen new Democratic senators, he said, "16 have basically never said anything about crypto." He described Democratic staff with "a lot of internal anger about how the last two years played out, where a lot of people in tech, just to be frank, did become very close to the Trump administration," and he warned the industry against trying to "lean further in on being a single-party industry, which I think further heightens the danger." He repeated something he said he had argued in March, when it was unpopular: that it would have been better for crypto, over time, if Kamala Harris had won. Crypto, he said, "is a technical problem that needs a technical solution," and he called the alternative "moralistic." I agree with most of that. Crypto became a moral question when a sitting president sold a memecoin to his supporters and [invited its largest holders to dinner](/posts/2026-02-08-cathedral-to-casino-how-crypto-lost-the-cypherpunk-plot), and when the industry spent [more than $200 million](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/crypto-industry-spends-more-than-200-million-to-sway-the-midterms.html) on this year's elections. Many of the people who lost money in those ventures were Trump's own supporters. A memecoin sold in his name, with a dinner offered to its largest holders, was not aimed at Elizabeth Warren's voters. Speculators were among the buyers too, and the largest holders were buying access as much as a coin, and they got the access. A supporter who bought a smaller amount got a coin that fell in value. The disclosure and conflict-of-interest rules Warren has pressed for would have protected buyers like that supporter. Slaughter's advice to the industry is to meet the freshmen on the cost of living and be ready for the question he expects Democrats to ask: "why is this not ripping me off?" As a Democratic senator, he said, he would have made the CLARITY Act guarantee that crypto jobs spread beyond "the coastal megalopolis," and that when stablecoins need a bank, "it should be a community bank or a regional bank." It is a pitch built for social democrats, an industrial policy with crypto inside it, and it may persuade some of them. In thirty-seven minutes on how the industry should approach the new Democrats, nobody on the episode mentioned privacy, self-custody, the pardons, or the developers in prison. The administration the industry helped elect [pardoned Ross Ulbricht](https://www.npr.org/2025/01/21/nx-s1-5270051/trump-pardons-dark-web-marketplace-silk-road-ross-ulbricht) on its second day and, in October 2025, [pardoned Changpeng Zhao](https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cly1qrl9l1qo), the billionaire founder of Binance, who had pleaded guilty to failing to maintain an effective anti-money-laundering program. Within a month, Keonne Rodriguez and William Hill, who built the Samourai Wallet, [were sentenced](https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/founders-samourai-wallet-cryptocurrency-mixing-service-sentenced-five-and-four-years) to five and four years in prison after pleading guilty to conspiring to run a money-transmitting business that knowingly moved criminal proceeds. Roman Storm, a developer of the Tornado Cash mixer, [was convicted](https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2025/08/06/roman-storm-guilty-of-unlicensed-money-transmitting-conspiracy-in-partial-verdict) of conspiring to run an unlicensed money-transmitting business in August 2025 and faces a retrial, [set for April 2027](https://cryptobriefing.com/roman-storm-retrial-postponed-april-2027/), on the charges the jury could not decide. Prosecutors cited Hill recommending Samourai on a darknet forum to "clean dirty BTC" and Rodriguez describing mixing as "money laundering for bitcoin," and at Rodriguez's sentencing Judge Denise Cote [said](https://sg.news.yahoo.com/samourai-wallet-developer-sentenced-5-170830441.html), "We all want financial privacy. But I don't think that's really what was at stake here." The pardons went to the exchange founder and the marketplace operator, and the wallet developers went to prison. In May, Rodriguez [wrote](https://x.com/keonne/status/2052066547561070671) that "one must come to terms with the fact that I am simply a federal prisoner without money, power, or influence, and I will serve my full sentence." ## A Bank Unto Yourself When [Kraken stopped Monero trading](https://support.kraken.com/ca/articles/notice-of-delisting-xmr-canada) for its Canadian clients in September 2025, "due to compliance requirements in Canada," it left withdrawals open, and anyone who moved coins to their own wallet kept them. Binance [dropped Monero](https://www.theblock.co/post/276176/binance-delisting-monero) in February 2024, and the network carried on. A Monero wallet on your own computer asks no one's permission, and no compliance department or legislature can reach into it. In 2006 two of Tor's designers, Roger Dingledine and Nick Mathewson, published a paper titled ["Anonymity Loves Company: Usability and the Network Effect."](https://www.freehaven.net/anonbib/cache/usability:weis2006.pdf) Their subject was usability, and their finding was that a privacy tool protects people only in proportion to its crowd. "Anonymity networks work by hiding users among users," they wrote, so "when more users join the network, existing users become more secure, even if the new users never talk to the existing ones!" Alice and Bob, the cryptographers' stock correspondents, "can't get anonymity by themselves." Monero builds the crowd into every payment. When you spend Monero, the protocol hides the coin you are spending among fifteen decoys drawn from other people's past transactions, a ring of sixteen [since a 2022 upgrade](https://www.getmonero.org/2022/04/20/network-upgrade-july-2022.html), so the privacy of each payment is made from the outputs of strangers. An upgrade called [FCMP++](https://github.com/seraphis-migration/monero/releases/tag/v0.19.0.0-beta.3.1), now running on a test network, would replace the ring with a proof that the coin being spent is one of more than 150 million outputs on the chain, though no date has been set for it to reach the network people use. The crowd also protects socially. Holding Monero is unremarkable when ordinary people hold it, and conspicuous once the remaining holders are mostly the committed and the criminal, in whatever proportions a prosecutor or a bank chooses to describe. Delistings act on the crowd. They leave the coins already held untouched and decide who joins. The person who might have bought a little Monero in an app she already uses, the way most people bought their first bitcoin, now has to find a peer-to-peer market or a swap service, and most such people never will. The European Union's anti-money-laundering regulation, which [applies from July 10, 2027](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/1624/oj/eng), prohibits banks and crypto service providers, among others, from keeping any account that allows "the anonymisation or increased obfuscation of transactions, including through anonymity-enhancing coins." The same regulation exempts the makers of self-hosted wallets that cannot reach their users' coins, so a European who already holds Monero keeps it. I have tried to talk myself out of this. Perhaps a privacy coin is healthier off the regulated exchanges, where its price is less exposed to a compliance officer's mood and its users are people who meant to be there, and peer-to-peer markets and atomic swaps between bitcoin and Monero exist and work, so a network that survived Binance's departure has shown it does not need Binance. All of that is true for the people who already know how to use a swap service, which is to say people like me. The people who most need financial privacy are rarely like me. One is a woman traveling to another state for an abortion her own state has banned; another is an activist whose bank closed her organization's account last week. For them the way into a private coin runs through an exchange or a cash-out service with an address and a license, and a government knows where to find both. What I took for the cypherpunk position depends, more than I liked to admit, on how many strangers share it. Satoshi understood this in 2010. He told the forum that Bitcoin was too small to survive the attention of angry governments, and he asked for time to grow. Censorship resistance had preconditions, a crowd of users and software hardened against attack, and in December 2010 the network had neither. The places where governments press on a privacy network have not changed much since: the on-ramps and off-ramps where money becomes coins and coins become money again, and the developers who can be named and charged. Anyone who holds a privacy coin for its privacy therefore has a stake in the politics they hoped to be done with, and after November 3 a large part of that politics belongs to the left. ## Who Holds the Switch The left that just won wants more of what the cypherpunks wanted than either side tends to admit. In 2022 Representative Stephen Lynch introduced the [ECASH Act](https://ecashact.us/), with Rashida Tlaib, Ayanna Pressley, Jesús García, and Alma Adams as cosponsors, to have the Treasury issue a digital dollar that, in its sponsors' words, "replicates the offline-capable, peer-to-peer, privacy-respecting, zero transaction-fee, and payable-to-bearer features of physical cash." The devices holding it could contain no "surveillance, personal identification or transactional data-gathering, or censorship-enabling backdoor features." Its sponsors present it as a way "to promote equity and justice for historically marginalized communities," and its FAQ, asking whether e-cash involves blockchain, answers "No." Lynch [reintroduced it in 2023](https://lynch.house.gov/2023/9/rep-lynch-reintroduces-legislation-to-develop-electronic-version-of-u-s-dollar-and-announces-congressional-digital-dollar-caucus), and I can find no version in the current Congress. In Europe, the Socialists and Democrats, the center-left group in the European Parliament, call the digital euro, now in negotiation between Parliament and the member states, ["a sovereign public instrument that puts people before profit,"](https://www.socialistsanddemocrats.eu/newsroom/sds-got-digital-euro-right-protecting-merchants-and-europes-sovereignty) usable offline and by people "without a bank account." The Spanish socialist Jonás Fernández summed up the group's aims as "Sovereignty, accessibility and privacy." Yanis Varoufakis, the former Greek finance minister, [wrote last year](https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2025/07/12/a-trust-fund-for-everyone-to-defuse-the-stablecoin-time-bomb/) that "common people" want stablecoins because "they offer a way to send money, especially abroad, that is cheaper, faster, immune to US sanctions, and more reliable than rickety inter-bank messaging systems such as SWIFT." His answer was a Federal Reserve wallet that could "guarantee that every payment or transfer is utterly private." Other people's switches drive the European argument. The S&D's case for the digital euro cites "the oligopoly of US card schemes such as Visa and Mastercard, which... have the power to exclude individuals from the payment system altogether, as we are witnessing in the case of judges of the International Criminal Court." One of those judges is Canadian. The United States [sanctioned Kimberly Prost](https://www.state.gov/releases/office-of-the-spokesperson/2025/08/imposing-further-sanctions-in-response-to-the-iccs-ongoing-threat-to-americans-and-israelis) in August 2025 "for ruling to authorize the ICC's investigation into U.S. personnel in Afghanistan." [NPR reported](https://www.npr.org/2026/10/01/nx-s1-5977815/trump-icc-sanctions-kimberly-prost) in October that her credit cards, "issued in the Netherlands and Canada, were canceled," that even small transfers from her remaining accounts could be blocked, and that by August nine of the court's eighteen judges were under US sanctions. "We have this massive overcompliance by companies," Prost said. "I went home and Alexa wouldn't talk to me." Brazil met the same power through its public payment system. In July 2025 the US Trade Representative [opened an investigation](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-07-18/pdf/2025-13498.pdf) of Brazil that faulted it, among other things, for "advantaging its government-developed electronic payment services." In June [it found](https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2026-11158) that Brazil's treatment of Pix, the free instant-payment system its central bank launched in 2020 and which the notice calls "its national champion," was "unfair and discriminatory." In July, on that finding and others, the United States [put a 25 percent tariff](https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2026-14542) on Brazilian goods. This is the problem WikiLeaks met in 2010, now arriving at institutions the left defends. A payment company, or a government standing behind one, decides that a publisher or a judge should be cut off, and nothing in the design of the card networks prevents it. A government decides that another country's public payment system is an unfair trade practice. The European left has learned from the receiving end that whoever holds the switch can be the wrong person, and its answer is to build a switch of its own, under public control. The cypherpunk and the social democrat now both say privacy should be built into digital money, and ECASH's list of features could have been posted to the cypherpunks' mailing list. The social democrat wants privacy granted by a public issuer, written into statute and designed by a central bank, so that it can be governed. The cypherpunk wants privacy as a property of the system that no issuer can revoke, which means that in the ordinary sense it cannot be governed at all. A privacy that one government grants, a later government can take back. ECASH's guarantees would have lasted exactly as long as Congress and the Treasury chose to keep them, and Americans on the left have just spent two years watching who can end up running the Treasury. The European Union that promises a private digital euro has already barred its banks and crypto service providers from handling private money it does not issue. The switch has been used in my own country, with the left's votes. On February 14, 2022, the federal government invoked the Emergencies Act against the convoy occupying downtown Ottawa and ordered banks to freeze accounts linked to it, and a week later the NDP [voted with the Liberals](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/trudeau-emergencies-act-vote-1.6359243) to confirm the declaration. Most of the roughly $1 million in crypto donated to the convoy [escaped seizure](https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/freedom-convoy-cryptocurrency-asset-seizure-1.6389601). In January 2024 a Federal Court judge [ruled](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/emergencies-act-federal-court-1.7091891) that "there was no national emergency justifying the invocation of the Emergencies Act" and that the account freezes violated the Charter, and in January of this year [the Federal Court of Appeal agreed](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/convoy-protest-emergencies-act-appeal-9.7046769) that the protests "fell well short of a threat to national security." In Canada, crypto's censorship resistance has been most visible on the right. A left that wants a private digital dollar for Kimberly Prost will have to want it for the convoy's donors too. I am not sure the cypherpunks win this argument on the merits. A digital euro that works offline and is private by law could protect far more people than Monero ever will, because hundreds of millions of people might use it, and a crowd is what privacy needs. A social democrat can fairly say that a coin as small as Monero protects almost no one, whatever its cryptography. I do not know how to weigh a large crowd under an issuer who might turn on it against a small crowd under no issuer at all. I suspect a free society needs both, a public cash for the crowd and a bearer coin for the day the public issuer turns, and I cannot yet say how a legislature would write that down. ## Catia La Mar The case for crypto that a social democrat could accept on its own terms comes from Venezuela, and it looks very little like the industry's case. Two earthquakes, of magnitude 7.2 and 7.5, struck the country on June 24. [GiveDirectly](https://www.givedirectly.org/venezuela-earthquakes-blog), the charity that sends unconditional cash to people in poverty, wanted to pay survivors in Catia La Mar, a town on the coast of La Guaira state, and two governments stood in the way: American sanctions limited which banks would touch a transfer into Venezuela, and a 2024 Venezuelan law restricted nonprofits. Other responders treated the country's mobile payment system, Pago Móvil, as off-limits because of its ties to state-owned banks. GiveDirectly's route ran through crypto. Coinbase converted donated dollars into USDC, a dollar stablecoin, on the Stellar network; a compliance firm screened the transfers; and cashiers on Airtm's peer-to-peer marketplace bought the USDC and paid recipients in bolívares through Pago Móvil. Each of 3,765 people received $340. The first payments went out 21 days after the earthquakes, and 86 cents of every donated dollar reached the people it was meant for. Hector, who is 57, said "it fell from the sky, because I used it to partly rebuild what the earthquake destroyed. And I still have further to go." The money lasted about three weeks. The recipients never held a stablecoin, since GiveDirectly paid them in bolívares, "which exposed our transfers to inflation." And the route had an exchange at its narrowest point. The cashiers "typically used crypto markets, including Binance," and "a Binance maintenance window in late July caused a liquidity shortage that delayed payments." A social democrat can support every part of that. A charity got donated money to disaster victims in three weeks, around a sanctions regime on one side and a restrictive government on the other, and the recipients never needed to know what a stablecoin was. It is also the part of crypto that delistings and off-ramp rules reach first. The stablecoin is issued by a company that can freeze it, and the cashiers depended on an exchange that answers to regulators in several countries. In the United States, Ro Khanna makes a version of this case. The California Democrat, whom Slaughter placed among "the people who are aligned with the Bernie camp," [told Bitcoin Magazine](https://bitcoinmagazine.com/politics/congressman-ro-khanna-says-democrats-are-changing-their-tune-on-bitcoin) in March 2025 that "the Democratic Party should be embracing it as something that can create financial empowerment for people," and in October 2025 he [introduced a resolution](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hres849ih/html/BILLS-119hres849ih.htm) supporting a ban on officials and their families issuing or endorsing crypto. He holds the empowerment case and the anti-corruption case at once, and among national progressives I have found no one else who does. Outside the United States, the clearest left-coded case is older. In October 2020 the Feminist Coalition, a group of young Nigerian women raising money for protesters in the #EndSARS movement against police brutality, [lost its bank account](https://finance.yahoo.com/news/nigerian-banks-shut-them-activists-145501135.html) once its role in the protests became known. It added a bitcoin option and within about a week had [raised roughly 9.9 bitcoin](https://nairametrics.com/2020/10/22/endsars-feminist-coalition-raise-cryptos-worth-126000/). Back in the United States, the poverty story is weaker than either Khanna or I would like. In a January survey, [Pew found](https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/06/08/about-1-in-5-americans-have-used-crypto-republicans-use-has-ticked-up/) that 19 percent of American adults have used crypto and that the growth since 2021 came mostly from upper-income adults and Republicans; among lower-income adults the figure was 16 percent, essentially unchanged in five years. Where crypto does reach poor American neighborhoods, it often arrives as a crypto ATM, and [economists at INET found](https://www.ineteconomics.org/perspectives/blog/move-fast-and-break-everything-crypto-and-the-democrats) the machines concentrated there. Stephen Diehl, [writing in *Current Affairs*](https://www.currentaffairs.org/news/why-democrats-need-to-fight-the-crypto-industry), calls this "predatory inclusion," a phrase that fits more of the American evidence than I expected when I started reading. In Canada the left has been silent. I could find no statement on crypto from the NDP or its leader, [Avi Lewis](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-new-leader-avi-lewis-9.7146004), who campaigned instead on [postal banking](https://lewisforleader.ca/ideas/public-options-full-plan/) for the million or so Canadians the banks underserve, with "affordable remittance services to those sending money abroad." Crypto entered Canadian politics as [Pierre Poilievre's issue](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/poilievre-crypto-explainer-1.6653739), and the Liberal government's [Stablecoin Act](https://www.dlapiper.com/en/insights/publications/2026/04/canada-enacts-framework-to-regulate-stablecoin-in-bill-c-15), passed in March, puts issuers under Bank of Canada supervision and forbids them to pay interest. ## The Small Beta Community Bitcoin outgrew the danger Satoshi described. It has exchange-traded funds and a lobby that can spend $64 million against a single Senate candidate, and no one government can now shut it down. The small beta community of 2010 is now the privacy end of crypto: Monero, and the wallets and mixers whose developers are in prison or awaiting trial, delisted across much of the world and eight months from exclusion from Europe's regulated market. What I would ask of the left that just won is narrower than what the industry asks, and the industry will not ask it. Regulate the custodians and the casino as hard as the evidence warrants. Leave self-custody alone, and protect developers whose software never touches anyone's money, as the Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act (BRCA) would; Slaughter [has heard](https://unchainedcrypto.com/paradigms-justin-slaughter-calls-clarity-act-dead-outlines-house-democrats-crypto-bill/) that the House Democrats' draft would be "much stricter than the BRCA" on DeFi. Keep the ramps open for coins whose only offense is privacy, since closing them shrinks the crowd for everyone who holds them lawfully. And when you build public digital cash, as I hope you will, build it as a bearer instrument that you yourselves could not switch off, because you have now seen who else gets to sit in that chair. Satoshi asked for time so the network could grow before the heat arrived. For the privacy end of crypto the heat has arrived, and growth is still the only defense he ever proposed. Brussels has already decided how much harder it will be for ordinary Europeans to reach a private coin legally. Washington will decide over the next two years, much of it through Democrats who, by Slaughter's count, have never said anything about crypto. The industry will ask them about community banks and jobs outside the coasts. Someone else will have to ask them about Kimberly Prost's credit cards, and about the strangers whose coins make a Monero payment private. *Disclosure: I hold bitcoin and some Monero, and I work at [Templar Labs](https://www.tplr.ai), which builds decentralized AI training infrastructure.*